Do We Even Need to Buy Brand Names?
Imagine this all-too-familiar scenario: you are gracefully steering your slightly wobbly shopping cart through the automatic sliding doors of the supermarket, clutching a long, messy shopping list in your hand. The bright fluorescent lights hum overhead, the scent of the bakery wafts through the air, and you’re mentally calculating the rising cost of groceries. As you walk through the aisles, navigating around other shoppers, you suddenly remember there’s a powerful yet incredibly simple frugal strategy you can use to save an average of 33% on your entire purchase, maybe even more.
It doesn’t require any kind of tedious coupon cutting, downloading multiple apps, or signing up for yet another rewards card that clutters your wallet. The best part of it all is that you still get to buy every single item on the list, from pantry staples to cleaning supplies. You only need to make one simple switch: buy private-label products instead of the heavily advertised brand-name products. Now, this is a game-changing thought that could pop into your mind IF and only IF you already read this article. It’s a strategy that saves you money, supports the store you shop at, and introduces you to some fantastic new products. I’m just saying it’s a win-win situation, and you’re about to learn how to master it.
What are private-label products?
Also referred to as “store brand,” “house brand,” or simply “generics”, private-label products are a wide range of items that are sold under a specific retailer’s own brand name. These products are oftentimes manufactured by a third-party supplier or co-packer and then offered exclusively under that retailer’s brand. You see them everywhere: Costco has Kirkland Signature, Target has Good & Gather, Walmart has Great Value, and Whole Foods has 365. Some of these suppliers specialize in creating only store-brand products, while others are actually well-known brand-name manufacturers who use their existing facilities and expertise to make value-brand products in a non-competitive category (such as a brand-name ketchup producer that could manufacture a store-brand tomato paste, for instance). This practice is incredibly common and efficient.
In certain circumstances, and more often than you’d think, a single large-scale supplier could be providing similar products (with completely different recipes, formulas, and packaging) for a wide variety of different store brands across the country. This is a testament to the scale and sophistication of the modern food production industry, allowing for immense variety while keeping costs down through shared manufacturing infrastructure.
Why are they much cheaper?
The primary reason private labels are able to sell their products for way less is stunningly simple: their marketing and advertising costs are a tiny fraction of their brand-name counterparts. National brands spend billions of dollars each year on television commercials, celebrity endorsements, glossy magazine ads, social media campaigns, and prominent event sponsorships. They are fighting for your attention and loyalty, and that fight is incredibly expensive. Come to think about it, when was the last time you actually saw a Super Bowl commercial for a store’s no-name tortilla chips or their house-brand mustard? Probably never.
Well, who cares about that when they can pass those massive savings along to us, the customers? That’s the beauty of the model. Interestingly enough, even if they are priced more cheaply for the consumer, store brands generally provide the supermarket with a significantly higher profit margin than brand names do. This creates a powerful incentive for the store to not only stock these items but also to ensure they are of high quality. When a product carries the store’s name, its quality reflects directly on the store’s reputation. So not only are generics a proper deal for you, but they are also quite good for the store’s bottom line, ensuring they’ll continue to invest in improving their private-label lines.
What about the difference in quality?
One of the biggest obstacles in switching over to a store brand is quite a psychological one: getting over this whole idea that a famous brand name should automatically imply top-notch quality is just false. This perception is carefully cultivated through decades of marketing that links brands with feelings of comfort, trust, and nostalgia. We’ve also all had to experience disappointment at some point after straying from a trusted brand-name product, but to let one bad experience convince you that all off-brand products are low quality means you are definitely missing out on wonderful deals, but also on some genuinely great products.
The reality is that the quality gap has narrowed dramatically, and in many cases, has disappeared entirely. In a Consumer Reports taste test, for example, over 60% of store-brand items were judged as good as or even better tasting than the national brand-name items. In the most recent years, retailers have been doing their part to make their own store brands something a bit more appealing and even aspirational to shoppers. They’ve done this by updating their branding and packaging designs to look more modern and appealing, and also by including exciting specialty and premium products in their store-brand lineup, like organic snacks, imported cheeses, or plant-based foods. Some grocery stores such as Target (Good & Gather), Trader Joe’s, and Costco (Kirkland Signature) have succeeded in building extreme brand loyalty to their store-brand products, to the point where people shop there *specifically* for those items.
Single-ingredient? Well, it’s a no-brainer.
When something on your shopping list has a single, simple ingredient, it’s quite hard to justify paying a lot more just to get a brand name on the label. After all, salt is still sodium chloride, and household bleach is just sodium hypochlorite solution, regardless of who packages it. The same goes for a huge array of simple pantry items like all-purpose flour, granulated sugar, baking soda, corn starch, basic spices, plain oats, and dried beans. These are commodity items, and the brand name adds little to no intrinsic value.
This logic extends to many other areas as well. For fresh produce, you can learn to read the signs for freshness—like color, firmness, and scent—way before defaulting to the label on a bag of carrots. Other kitchen cupboard staples like nuts, dried fruits, and many canned foods are interchangeable for the most part. With canned goods, it’s generally a good idea to check the ingredients list to see if there are any differences in preservatives or additives that could affect your decision, such as comparing the sodium content in canned beans or checking if fruit is packed in syrup or its own juice. But often, the core product is identical.
Play with preference
Take a moment to conduct a “pantry audit.” You can take a peek inside your fridge and pantry and try to take note of the products for which you consistently buy brand names. After all, is there a specific, tangible reason why you have never strayed from them? Do you even have a real, tested preference for the taste, or are you simply getting them because that’s what your parents bought or because of marketing-driven habit?
It’s an eye-opening exercise. You might discover that your loyalty is based more on autopilot than on actual preference. Substituting the occasional brand-name stock, seasoning, or sauce with a store brand can be a wonderful, low-risk way to save money while exploring brand-new flavor profiles. You might even find a new favorite that costs half as much. Start small: pick one or two “autopilot” items and commit to trying the store-brand version on your next shopping trip.
Be selective about your brand loyalty
Naturally, this isn’t to say you should abandon all brand names forever. Sometimes a brand-name product will definitely outperform its generic version, especially for items with complex, proprietary formulas. However, before you automatically reach for that familiar national brand, you should pause and consciously ask yourself if that perceived superior performance is truly worth the extra expense for your specific needs.
You might also find that some items in your shopping cart are totally non-negotiable, as others have more relaxed requirements. For instance, shelling out for brand-name super-soft tissues with lotion could genuinely mean the world to someone who suffers through a bad cold or allergy season, but for the occasional nose-blower, a basic store-brand box of tissues might do the trick perfectly well. The same might apply to diapers, where one brand’s fit might prevent leaks better for your child, or a specific brand of coffee that just hits the spot like no other. Be critical and selective about which specific products truly deserve your brand loyalty and your hard-earned cash.
Make room for some trial and error
We sometimes tend to be creatures of habit, and as a result, it can be quite difficult and even a little uncomfortable to introduce change into our established shopping routines. It’s important to accept that not every single generic product you will try might be a winner, but that doesn’t mean there aren’t any generic winners out there waiting to be discovered. So, keep searching and treat it like a low-stakes experiment.
Instead of overhauling your entire shopping list all at once, which can feel overwhelming, you can try swapping out just one or two products every single time you go to the store. Think of it as the “One Swap a Shop” challenge. This gradual approach allows you to see what truly works for you and your family without a major commitment. As time goes by, you will be able to keep your household running just as smoothly as before, but you’ll have the added satisfaction of watching the savings add up at the checkout.
Store-brand items to buy
If you’re still deciding which store brands to get, it’s important to be open to the idea that each decision might differ, and what works in one store might not in another. The trick is to find those many situations where opting for a store brand doesn’t make any kind of discernible difference in terms of flavor and quality and try to enjoy the significant savings you can unlock. It’s a skill that improves with practice.
This smart grocery shopping habit might help save hundreds, or even thousands, of dollars per year. There are plenty of store-brand items you can consider to stretch your grocery budget as far as it gets. Key categories include:
- Pantry Staples: As mentioned, items like flour, sugar, salt, cooking oils, pasta, rice, and canned beans are fantastic places to start.
- Cereal: Many store-brand “O’s” or “flakes” are produced in the same facilities as their expensive counterparts. Just compare the nutrition labels!
- Eggs and Dairy: Eggs are graded by the USDA, not the brand, so a Grade A egg is a Grade A egg. Milk, butter, sour cream, and basic cheeses are also excellent generic buys.
- Spices and Condiments: While you may have a favorite ketchup, basics like mustard, mayonnaise, and common dried spices are often indistinguishable.
- Frozen Foods: Simple frozen fruits and vegetables are perfect for store brands. The quality difference is often negligible, but the price difference is huge.
- Paper Goods and Cleaning Products: For many everyday messes, standard paper towels and napkins work fine. Likewise, the active ingredients in many cleaners, like bleach or ammonia, are chemically identical to the name brands.
- Over-the-Counter Medications: This is a huge one. The FDA mandates that generic drugs must contain the same active ingredients, at the same strength, as their brand-name versions. You can save substantially on pain relievers, allergy medicines, and cold remedies.
Store-brand items to skip
Naturally, there are some situations where the quality, taste, or performance of store-brand items could potentially fall short of their name-brand counterparts. Plenty of people have tasted a generic soda that just doesn’t capture that specific flavor they love, or a store-brand cake mix where the flavor or texture didn’t quite live up to the name-brand equivalent they grew up with. Complex recipes and unique flavor profiles can be hard to replicate perfectly.
Sometimes, the quality of store-brand products can turn out to be quite inferior in a way that negates the savings, too. Think of flimsy napkins or paper towels that are so thin you would need to use double or triple the product to clean up a simple mess, or a weak trash bag that tears while you’re taking it out. In these cases, paying a little more for the name brand is actually the more frugal choice. All in all, there’s no universal, specific list of generic items you should always skip.
For instance, a store-brand tomato sauce could taste horribly watery from one retailer and be rich and super good from another. In the end, buying private-label items might call for some strategic trial and error. To reduce the risk, look for satisfaction guarantees. Bonus points, if you shop somewhere such as Costco or Trader Joe’s, the warehouse store’s generous return policy allows you to return items you buy for virtually any reason, even if you simply didn’t like the way something tastes. Many other supermarkets offer similar guarantees on their own house brands, so don’t be afraid to ask!
Generic goods don’t win every single time in such a battle, but they win more often than you think. Did you know there might be some off-brand products that represent a tough competition to the originals, sometimes even developing their own cult following? The next time you feel like having a snack, you should give a store’s off-brand cheese crackers or chocolate-hazelnut spread a try. You’ll know what we’re talking about when you see the savings on your receipt.
If you’re happy you stumbled upon this article, we also recommend checking: Best 9 Places to Go Shopping in Tampa, FL
